Quote of the Day.

A reader eloquently chides Sully’s naivete about America’s history of conservative populism:

Your obvious shock and dismay at the sheer angry ignorance of the health care teabaggers reiterates my largest problem with your rosy immigrant’s view of America. You have often underestimated just how poisonously dangerous the American populist right is.

I don’t blame you. You came to America after the rise of Reagan. Most of your life in America, you have lived under different Republican presidents who placated these folks with platitudes and campaign rhetoric. The one period when the populist right didn’t feel they had a fellow traveler in charge was when Bill Clinton was elected (thanks to the reactionaries splitting their votes). You remember, no doubt, the level of crazy Clinton had to defuse and dodge, and this was a man who had the advantage of being a Southern bubba who has dealt which such people all his life.

For most of your time in America, this insanity has been muted by the success of conservative politics. Since you live in Washington, you probably saw daily the face of the successful conservative political establishment that milked the populist right, and by milking them kept their bitterness at a manageable level. That safety valve was stuffed up by George Bush’s failed presidency.

So now, these people are facing their worst fears; actual change.

A political and demographic re-alignment is happening before their eyes, and they are reaching back into their old bag of tricks of intimidation, violence, and apocalyptic fearmongering. You are British, Andrew. You love this country, and we love you for it. But you didn’t grow up around these folks, and you don’t realize what a permanent and potent part of the American political landscape they are.

They have always been with us, the people who believed in manifest destiny, who delighted in the slaughter of this land’s original inhabitants, who cheered a nation into a civil war to support an economic system of slavery that didn’t even benefit them. They are the people who bashed the unions and cheered on the anti-sedition laws, who joined the Pinkertons and the No Nothing Party, who beat up Catholic immigrants and occasionally torched the black part of town. They rode through the Southern pine forests at night, they banned non-European immigration, they burned John Rockefeller Jr. in effigy for proposing the Grand Tetons National Park.

These are the folks who drove Teddy Roosevelt out of the Republican Party and called his cousin Franklin a communist, shut their town’s borders to the Okies and played the protectionist card right up til Pearl Harbor, when they suddenly had a new foreign enemy to hate. They are with us, the John Birchers, the anti-flouride and black helicopter nuts, the squirrly commie-hating hysterics who always loved the loyalty oath, the forced confession, the auto-de-fe. Those who await with baited breath the race war, the nuclear holocaust, the cultural jihad, the second coming, they make up much more of America then you would care to think.

I’m always optimistic about America. We’re a naturally rich and beautiful place. Every generation we renew ourselves with a watering of immigrants committed to the American dream, immigrants like you. But please, Andrew, do not for a second underestimate the price in blood and tears we’ve always paid here for progress.

I voted for Obama with my fingers crossed, because I knew that as the populist right lost power, they would become more extreme, more concentrated, and more violent. As to dismissing them as only a quarter or so of America, please remember that it only took a quarter or so of Americans to actively support the Confederacy.

5 thoughts on “Quote of the Day.

  1. lsn August 8, 2009 at 9:26 pm Reply

    I visited the museum at the St Louis Arch in June, which has a display of highlights on a year by year basis from 1800-1900. It amazed me just how many lynch mobs made it into the highlights, and how many of the mobs were running amok over such bizarrely trivial (um, to me) things.

    I feel for Sully – I have the same sense of utter disbelief and surreality at the crap the US right is coming out with and the sheer level of hatred they exude. When you come from a place where lynch mobs have never really been the norm, it’s quite shocking to be suddenly confronted by their descendants.

  2. blackink August 9, 2009 at 11:40 am Reply


    We have really short memories in this country. And I think that point about “blood and tears” in the name of progress was an important one.

    I don’t think we’re anywhere near as civilized as we tend to think we are. And it worries me that, over the past few months, the rhetoric from the “conservative populists” – to be kind – has gotten more unhinged and completely detached from reality.

  3. Susana August 9, 2009 at 3:40 pm Reply

    Thanks. Phenomenal post I’ve been thinking about for two days

  4. Molly August 10, 2009 at 9:26 am Reply


  5. ladyfresh August 10, 2009 at 11:32 am Reply

    good reminder

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: